Sunday, April 19, 2020

Circuit breaker Day 13 pix: Next Fighter Replacement Programme Rafale & Eurofighter Typhoon

Test cell: An unpainted Rafale having its engines tested in a hush house. The Rafale lost out to Boeing's F-15 Strike Eagle in the final evaluation of Singapore's Next Fighter Replacement Programme that sought to find a replacement for the A-4 Skyhawk.

As a journalist, I covered Singapore's Next Fighter Replacement Programme (NFRP) when it started in 1998 with six candidates - Boeing F-15E Strike Eagle & F-18E/F Super Hornet, Dassault Aviation Rafale, Eurofighter Typhoon, Lockheed Martin F-16E/F (or Block 60) and Sukhoi Su-30 - and wrote the NFRP's concluding news release seven years later when the F-15 was picked as the winner.

Six candidates became three after Singapore's Ministry of Defence and Republic of Singapore Air Force (RSAF) downselected the F-15 together with the two European contenders, the Rafale and Typhoon. Then it was F-15 versus Rafale in 2005. In September 2005, Boeing F-15T was declared winner of the seven year long evaluation (the designation was later changed to F-15SG).

I visited the aircraft production lines at Boeing, BAE Systems (which was testing the then-new Typhoon) and Dassault Aviation. Sitting through separate briefings by rival aircraft makers was an interesting experience. The opportunity to see three different production lines was also an eye-opener as it allowed one to compare different approaches to aircraft design and manufacturing philosophy, combat roles, and life cycle support.

Along the way, one can piece together the strengths and weaknesses of the NFRP candidates based on tidbits of information shared by rival campaigns during on-the-record briefings and informally.

When NFRP became a two horse race, I had hoped Singapore would pick the Rafale. A diversified fleet of frontline fast jets would have immunised the RSAF against issues that might arise from situations when dealing with a sole source supplier. Some Arab air forces operate a diversified fleet successfully with American-made F-16s or F-15s flying alongside frontline fighters from elsewhere. Looking at the Rafale's combat record, the warplane is no slouch in combat and would have been a worthy A-4 successor.

The Eurofighter Typhoon was another promising candidate. Alas, the platform was too new and, in my opinion, the lack of maturity counted against it. BAE Systems fronted the marketing campaign for the Eurofighter consortium. Their marketing and engineering teams did their best. But in the end, Typhoon's capabilities were based largely on promises of what was to come rather than what you could see. In hindsight, Typhoon achieved or exceeded every campaign promise. From a cold start, few platforms can beat Typhoon in QRA and its combat record has validated every claim BAE made.

It's interesting to think about what capabilities Rafale and Typhoon might have brought to the RSAF had either platform been selected. Even today, I track the combat experience of the NFRP candidates out of personal interest. I would compare what I read or see in videos with what was shared by the respective manufacturers more than 15 years ago to see what has changed since then.


Year 2000: I met the Rafale at Dassault's flight test facility in Istres (below) and also at Dassault's aircraft plant near Paris where heaps of Mirages were being overhauled.

Year 2002: With BAE Systems and an early model Typhoon.

Saturday, April 18, 2020

Circuit breaker Day 12 pix: Leclerc MBT and tank factory visit

Special demo of the Leclerc MBT for visitors from Singapore. Yours truly holding the SG flag.

In the late 1990s, French weapons maker GIAT Industries tried to sell the Leclerc main battle tank to Singapore.

In May 1998, I flew to France to see the GIAT Industries tank factory in Roanne, in central France. The Roanne factory, which made the Leclerc MBT, was the first tank manufacturing facility that I ever visited. The factory had added significance for me because the Singapore Army's first light tank, the AMX-13, was made at the same factory in the 1950s. 

The French were excellent hosts. There was a briefing on the history of Roanne and a site walk that showed how they made the Leclerc, starting from steel plates all the way to the paint shop for newly-built tanks. The visit ended with a mobility demo by a Leclerc MBT plus a chance to speak to the three-man tank crew (driver, gunner and vehicle commander). Knowing my interest in the AMX-13, GIAT staff pointed out the buildings where the AMX-series was made. Many of these buildings had stayed virtually unchanged over the decades, with only internal machinery and jigs changed for different armoured vehicles.

The second stop in the itinerary was a visit to GIAT's artillery factory 220km away near the city of Bourges. The Bourges arsenal was special as this factory made the LG1 105mm light guns that GIAT supplied to the Singapore Artillery in the early 1990s. GIAT also showed their GCT 155mm self-propelled gun and brought me to an amazing museum dedicated to the study and documentation of artillery shells, rockets and fuzes. It was claimed that the museum had one example of virtually all Western-made shells dating back to the First World War. Looking at their extensive exhibits, there was no reason to doubt that claim. 

GIAT Industries Roanne tank factory

The GIAT Industries tank factory in Roanne was the place that made the AMX-13 light tanks used by the Singapore Army. Factory buildings stayed virtually unchanged since the AMX-series was made there.

GIAT Industries, Bourges

The GIAT artillery shell museum in the Bourges arsenal. Note the mine-clearing line charge between the two green pillars on the right. The museum has a heavy emphasis on artillery as the Bourges arsenal has traditionally been the place that makes tube artillery for the French Army.

Friday, April 17, 2020

Circuit breaker Day 11 pix: Singapore Police Force STAR unit

 
I love writing about special forces. The unit esprit, discipline, tenacity, courage and determination to give their all no matter what the odds always leaves one in awe.

Here's the Singapore Police Force (SPF) Special Tactics and Rescue (STAR) unit at a capability demo in 2004. In September 2007, STAR recaptured Dave Teo, the full-time National Serviceman who ran away with his SAR-21 rifle and ammunition from Mandai Hill Camp. Incidentally, the camp is down the road from the SPF training village where these pictures were taken.

Vigilance. Valour. Victory!





Thursday, April 16, 2020

Circuit breaker Day 10 pix: Peace Carvin II 20th anniversary F-16 tail art


These Republic of Singapore Air Force (RSAF) F-16Ds with the Peace Carvin II detachment at Luke Air Force Base (AFB) have something special beneath the covers. The fighters were painted with commemorative tail flashes to mark the 20th year of PC II in 2013.


On 18 December 2013, then United States Pacific Air Force commander, General Hawk Carlisle, did the honours with Major-General Hoo Cher Mou, who was then RSAF Chief of Air Force. 

The F-16Ds serve a joint RSAF-USAF command within the 425th Fighter Squadron of the 56th Fighter Wing at Luke AFB.

Here's something you may find interesting. The four tail flashes on the top row were ideas that were not chosen. I must say all the tail flashes look great and the winning choices certainly look stunning.




On December 11th, 2013, General Hawk Carlisle (left), who was then PACAF commander, and Maj. Gen. Hoo Cher Mou, then RSAF Chief of Air Force, took the wraps off two newly-painted F-16D tail flashes following the Peace Carvin II Parade. The specially commissioned tail flashes, which were picked from among six proposed designs, commemorate the 20th anniversary of the RSAF partnering with Luke AFB in training fighter pilots.

These pictures were taken during my first trip to Luke AFB, which is near the city of Phoenix in Arizona. MINDEF flew me there to see Exercise Forging Saber. I was the only reporter who extended my stay in Phoenix after the exercise. Am glad I did as it gave me the opportunity to see Phoenix firsthand and visit places like Tempe. Also drove 122 miles alone on Interstate 10 to see the aircraft boneyard at Davis-Monthan AFB, then a little farther to visit the Titan Missile Museum, then back to Phoenix in the evening. I left Phoenix before sunrise when it was pitch dark on the I-10. It was only during the drive back when I realised that I had driven through beautiful desert scenary, the kind you see in cowboy and red indian movies. I saw signs along the I-10 pointing to Marana and realised PV is literally in the middle of.... nowhere [which worries me now because I wonder how medical facilities in the area will cope with a spike in demand]. 

If you're reading this from PC II, PV or PC V, I hope you and your loved ones are keeping well. We're watching the US numbers very closely, as I'm sure you are too for the case of Singapore! Every night, many of us stay up for the latest data on SG's COVID-19 cases. 

Chin up. Stay healthy.

Wednesday, April 15, 2020

Circuit breaker Day 9 pix: Centurion main battle tank


This intriguing picture of a Centurion MBT appeared in Taiwanese defence forums some time ago. Am told it isn't photoshopped...

Tuesday, April 14, 2020

Circuit breaker Day 8 pix: Republic of Singapore Navy submarine RSS Chieftain commissioning ceremony



Over the years, I've seen the Republic of Singapore Navy (RSN) launch, commission and decommission its ships.

The commissioning ceremony for RSS Chieftain (ex-Royal Swedish Navy HMS Sjöhunden) on 24 August 2002 at Changi Naval Base was special as it was the only time I'd seen a submarine commissioned into service.

I've never been aboard an RSN sub. Operational subs that hosted me were from the US Navy (Los Angeles-class USS Bremerton) and the Royal Australian Navy (Collins-class).

Here's RSS Chieftain on her special day 18 years ago.




Monday, April 13, 2020

Circuit breaker Day 7 pix: Republic of Singapore Air Force RSAF Boeing F-15SG Roll-out ceremony


In November 2008, I saw the Boeing F-15SG Strike Eagle, the newest Republic of Singapore Air Force (RSAF) fighter jet, for the first time at the Boeing plant in St Louis, Missouri. The above picture was the first one I took with the F-15SG, which carried the United States Air Force serial number AF05-0001.[A note on the SG flag: This same flag followed me on assignments to cover four Singapore Armed Forces overseas operations. These were the earthquake relief mission in Taiwan, East Timor, Northern Arabian Gulf and the tsunami relief mission. So it's quite special to me and I brought it along for the F-15SG roll-out ceremony.]

The trip to St Louis came some 10 years after I first began writing about the RSAF's search for a A-4 Skyhawk replacement under its Next Fighter Replacement Programme (NFRP). The evaluation began with six candidates. These were the Boeing F-15E Strike Eagle, Boeing F/A-18E/F, Dassault Aviation Rafale, Eurofighter Typhoon (marketed by BAE Systems), Lockheed Martin F-16 and the Sukhoi Su-30. The list was whittled down to the F-15, Rafale and Typhoon, with the F-15 and Rafale down selected for the final phase.

In December 2005, the Singapore Ministry of Defence announced that it had signed a contract with Boeing to buy 12 F-15SGs with an option for eight more. Singapore eventually grew its F-15SG force to 40 planes.

On 3 November 2008, Boeing staged the roll-out ceremony for the first article, AF05-0001. Here're  some pictures from that event, graced by then RSAF Chief of Air Force, Major-General Ng Chee Khern.

 A special cake to celebrate the event.

 First group photo with the AF05-0001.



Souvenirs from the roll-out ceremony. I was given one Lion Head folder with the press release and speeches. But there was a stack leftover after the ceremony which they would have binned/recycled anyway, so I asked for a few more.